Sonicare Protectiveclean 4100, 5100 and 6100 are the new mid-range electric toothbrush models by Philips Sonicare. They were commissioned in March 2018 to cater for the increased demand for gum care products hence the name ProtectiveClean . So what exactly differentiates the models from the array of Sonicare models in the market?
ProtectiveClean, 4100 plaque control vs. 5100 gum health vs. 6100 Whitening rechargeable electric toothbrush.
Though they share the name Protective clean they are differentiated by the different model numbers. So what exactly marks one model from the other?
The 4100 has one cleaning mode and is designed for plaque control. However, this does not mean that the 5100 and 6100 are not good at removing plaque. They are actually as good as the 4100 in removing plaque but they can do much more based on the extra cleaning modes they have (gum care and whitening) and variable settings in the case of the ProtectiveClean 6100. For a better comparison of the protective, we shall pair each mode against the other.
Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 4100 vs 5100: What are the Differences
The 4100 has one cleaning mode: daily clean that is designed for optimal plaque removal. The 5100 has three cleaning modes (clean, gum care and white).
The 5100 has cleaning mode LED light and buttons on the handle while the 4100 does not have.
- The 4100 comes fitted with the plaque control brush head while the 5100 has 2 brush head, the gum care, and optimal white brush head.
- The 4100 is cheaper than 5100
- The 4100 comes in 5 colors for your convenience. These are (Pink, Black, Light Blue, Navy blue, deep pink) as compared to the 5100 that has 4 colors (Black-grey, white, turquoise and pastel pink).
Both 5100 and 4100 are quality toothbrushes that employ Sonicare’s flagship cleaning technology that is scientifically proven to remove plaque than a manual toothbrush. The 5100 gives you more options like using the gum care mode to zero down of cleaning under your gums or whitening your teeth. It also has automatic syncing of brush heads to the correct cleaning mode. For more customization of your cleaning experience, the 5100 is the choice to go for.
4100 vs 6100 Comparison (Main differences)
- The 6100 has 3 cleaning modes (white, gum care and clean) compared to 1 cleaning mode in 4100.
- 4100 has standard cleaning intensity (no cleaning intensity variations) while the 6100 has 3 intensity variations (low, medium and high). Varied intensities that are in the 6100 give you more options to customize the brushing experience to suit your needs. For instance, if you have sensitive teeth, the low intensity will provide a gentle brushing experience. On the other hand, if you want to rid your teeth of clinging plaque or discoloration of teeth the high intensity will come in handy.
- The 6100 has 3 cleaning intensity and cleaning modes icons and LED light on the handle which the 4100 does not have.
- The 6100 comes with the white brush head compared to the 4100 that has plaque control brush head.
- The 6100 has brush synch automatic pairing in which the brush head with intuitively select the appropriate cleaning mode suitable for the brush head slotted in the handle.
- The 6100 is more costly in comparison to the 4100.
- The 6100 comes in 5 colors (Black silver, white silver, pink pastel, navy blue, and deep purple) that differ slightly to the 4100 that has (deep pink, navy blue, light blue, pink and black).
- The 6100 has an additional button on the handle to control the cleaning modes.
- 6100 comes with a traveling case that is not available in the 4100.
The 4100 is a decent medium priced toothbrush that also has a pressure sensor. It cleans just as well as the 6100 because they both run on the same patented sonic cleaning technology that makes 62000 movements (31000 brush strokes per minute) which whips your toothpaste into bubbles that sweep between the teeth to fight hidden plaque. For basic cleaning, the 4100 will give you good results but if you want more; like massaging your gums or whitening your teeth the 6100 is the obvious choice.
5100 vs 6100: What differentiates them?
- The 6100 has three intensities for cleaning (low medium and high) unlike 5100 that has no cleaning intensity variations.
- The 5100 comes with a gum care brush head while the 6100 comes with the optimal white brush head (you can buy any brush that will need your need at an extra cost and use it since the ProtectiveClean snap-on feature is compatible with most Sonicare brush heads).
- The 5100 has no brush sync pairing for cleaning modes, a feature that is available in the 6100.
- The 6100 comes in 5 colors (White silver, Black silver, deep purple, navy blue, and pink pastel ) compared to the 5100 that comes in 4 colors (Turquoise, black grey, pastel pink and white).
- The 6100 costs more than the others.
The 6100 has variable settings and three cleaning modes which in total gives you six customization settings to tackle every aspect of cleaning your mouth including massaging your gums on gum care mode paired with a low-intensity setting, whitening, plaque removal and more.
It is feature rich with premium quality. In terms of being a high-end product, it is definitely in that bracket of high-end Sonicare models and will, of course, provide you with more options than the 5100. However, for day to day cleaning and tackling problem areas like cleaning your gums, the 5100 is just as good albeit without all the premium features (variable setting) available in the 6100.
When it comes to choosing, it all comes down to you. What is it that you need in a toothbrush? If it is decent brushing experience, then 5100 is good for you but if you want more customization and to take things a notch higher, then the 6100 is for you.
So what are the Similarities between Sonicare Protective Clean 4100, 5100 and 6100
Both have a pressure sensor. This is a new feature that Sonicare was not keen on for a long time. However, feedback from the market has forced them to introduce it in their models. They started with the high range Sonicare FlexCare Platinum in 2016 that had an intuitive (not visible-only shown through an app) pressure sensor. In 2017 they introduced a visible pressure sensor ring in the new DiamondClean Smart range 9300,9500 and 9700. In 2018 the new Sonicare Protective Clean models 4100,5100 and 6100 both have a pressure sensor.
They both have quadpacer and timers to help you brush effectively and to the dentist recommended time of 2 minutes per brushing session. They also have an auto-stop feature that automatically switches off the brush if you allow the brushing session to come to an end at the recommended 2 minutes.
They all have the similar design, sleek, smooth with a matte finish. Unlike Oral B they have no rubber grip but are yet slip-free even when handled with water. Of course, the Protective clean 5100 gum health and 6100 whitening have cleaning mode and intensity settings on the handle which the 4100 does not have but the overall look and feel are more or less the same.
- The other similarity between the Protectiveclean range is that they all have Brush Sync. The brush sync is a technology that alerts you when your brush head is due for renewal. A microchip installed in the handles triggers the LED Light to flash to remind you that you need to change the brush head. Generally for a brush head to perform at its optimum level, it needs to be replaced after 3 months use. The brush Sync because it is quite easy to forget. As you know, a won out brush is not effective in keeping your teeth healthy.
- They both have the easy start which is an embedded feature in most Sonicare toothbrushes that reduces the intensity of vibrations for the first twelve days when you start using your brush to allow to get used to the Sonicare sonic cleaning experience.
- The RFID microchip is installed in both the 4100, 5100 and 6100. However, in the case of the 4100 the microchip only serves the purpose of reminding you to change your brush bush. As for the 5100 and 6100 the microchip serves a dual purpose. It also intuitively pairs the brush head with the recommended brush head for effective cleaning.
- The RFID microchip is quite insightful in the sense that is you brush two times in a day, the brush Synch will alert you to swap the brush head after 3 months. If you only brush once a day the microchip will not trigger the LED light in 3 months but in 6 months. In the case that you brush 3 times a day or brush longer than the recommended two minutes per day twice a day, the reminder will come on even before you hit 3 months. The microchip keeps a log on how often the brush is used as you use it. Once you reach the calibrated 3 months usage, the LED light will flash to signal you to replace your brush head.
- They all have a small bump at the back to allow the bush to lie in place without rolling.
- The handles of all protectiveclean range are water resistant and can be rinsed on tap water.
- They both come with a solid 3 years manufacturers guarantee which gives you peace of mind. In case something happens to the toothbrush, you have a guarantee to cover you.
- They all come fitted with a battery that the manufacturer guarantees to last at least two weeks. Our testers got 28 days on the 4100 brushing twice a day after a full charge; so it is possible to get more than the standard Sonicare 14 day battery life.
- All the models have a dual charging battery that supports both 100v and 240 volts so they can be charged on USA sockets and anywhere else in the world without a voltage adapter. In case you travel abroad, all you need is a compatible plug adapter that fits into the sockets to charge your toothbrush.
- They all have LED battery indicators. Green solid light indicates that the battery is fully charged. Flashing LED light is a sign that the battery is halfway charged (medium) while flashing amber LED light and three beeping sound signifies low battery. Amber LED flashes and five beeps signify that the battery is flat and cannot be used for any brush session until you charge your toothbrush.
- All Philips Sonicare toothbrush operates on the patented sonic brushing technology that makes 62000 movements (31000 brush strokes) per minute. These high octane movements whip your toothbrush into bubbles that sweep between your teeth and under the gum line to fight plaque and bad breath.
- All protectiveclean toothbrushes use soft silicone bristles that are safe and gentle on your gums. They are all suitable to be used on braces, crowns, veneers, and fillings.
- They all have tightly populated bristles whose tip is curved in a manner to easily access hard to reach places in teeth structure.
Review of the Sonicare ProtectiveClean 4100 vs. 5100 vs. 6100
- The 6100 is the one with the most features; it comes close to the new DiamondClean but not quite there yet.
- Both 5100 and 6100 have three cleaning modes (clean, gum care and whites).
- All protective clean models have a clean mode that provides essential daily clean and is powered by the patented Sonicare technology that makes 62000 movements per minute. They are all exceptional in general cleaning. However, you need to concentrate on certain areas like improving the health of your gums or whitening your teeth then the 5100 and 6100 are the options for you.
- The clean mode lasts for a standard 2 minutes, the white has a duration of 2 minutes and 30 seconds. The gum care takes up to 3 minutes to clean under the gums and to stimulate them for better blood flow.
- The clean mode available in all the ProtectiveClean range removes seven times more plaque than a manual toothbrush. The gum care cleaning mode that works well with the gum care brush head enhances gum health up to 100%. The white mode that operates best with the optimal white brush head can reduce up to 100% fewer stains in seven days.
- All the protective clean range have a Brush Sync feature that works on two levels. One is that is tracks how long and hard you have used the brush heads and reminds you when the time is up for you to replace them. The other level automatically pairs the brush head to the appropriate cleaning mode for optimum performance.
All in all, the protective clean is a fresh introduction by Sonicare which now embraces having a pressure sensor on their brushes. The 4100, 5100 and 6100 are adequate for general cleaning and will definitely leave your teeth plaque free and improve your gum health. As already mentioned these models are water resistant and can be rinsed using tap water.
Overall the protective clean modes are gentle and effective to use. The 4100 is the most cost-effective because it’s relatively cheap and still gives you quality cleaning sessions that will keep your oral hygiene in top condition. If however, you need to go an extra step and whiten your teeth or pay greater attention to the health of your gums then the 6100 and 5100 are preferable. The 6100 allows you to vary the intensity to what you feel most comfortable with. For instance, having the optimum white mode on high intensity will give quicker results in whitening your teeth. Similarly, someone with sensitive teeth may prefer low intensity with the gum care brush head and mode on for optimal performance. The 6100 is the most premium of the protective range.
With all the features included in the protective clean models, these are compelling toothbrushes that are a good fit for you.
Sonicare DiamondClean vs. ProtectiveClean
The protective clean model that can be meaningfully be compared to DiamondClean is the 6100.
Similarities between Sonicare DiamondClean 6100 vs. ProtectiveClean
- These two models both have brush sync feature that automatically pairs the brush head to the required cleaning mode.
- They both have smart timers and brushing pacers that helps you brush for the dentist recommended time.
- They both have a pressure sensor to alert you when you are brushing too hard.
- They both have variable cleaning intensities at least in the DiamondClean smart
- Their respective batteries last for at least 2 weeks after a full charge.
- They both come with a travel charger. However, the DiamondClean traveling case has a more premium look and feel to it.
Differences between DiamondClean vs. ProtectiveClean 6100
- The DiamondClean comes with a USB charging capability which the 6100 does not have
- The DiamondClean has a charging glass which is unavailable in the ProtectiveClean.
- The DiamondClean has five cleaning modes compared to the three cleaning modes in the 6100.
- The DiamondClean comes with at least 2 brushing heads which is unlike the 6100 that only comes with one brush head.
- DiamondClean comes in 4 colors while the 6100 comes in 5 colors.
Overall the 6100 could be an alternative to the DiamondClean given that it is slightly cheaper than the DiamondClean. Although it has fewer cleaning modes, it covers the modes that most people are likely to use often. For high-end premium features and comfort, the DiamondClean is a clear winner because it has features like 3D mouth mapping and more cleaning modes to make your cleaning session more comfortable.
Sonicare series 2 vs. Protectiveclean 4100
As already mentioned the 4100 is an improved version of the Series 2. These two models use the same brush head, the ProtectiveClean. They also have one cleaning mode that is designed to fight plaque in your teeth. The both use the sonic patented technology that makes 31000 brush strokes per minute.
Key Differences between Sonicare Protectiveclean 4100 vs. Series 2
The main difference is that the 4100 Protective clean has a pressure sensor that alerts you when you brush too hard.
They also have a brush sync feature which tracks how much you have used your brush. It will remind you to replace your brush head. This feature is not in the Series 2.
The series 2 removes up to 6 times of plaque in comparison with a manual brush while the 4100 removes plaque 7 times better than a manual brush.
The Series 2 comes with a NiMH battery which is not as long lasting as the Lithium battery that is the new Protectiveclean 4100.
Sonicare FlexCare vs. Protective clean
Philips Sonicare Flexcare is one of Sonicare’s premium toothbrushes. It was the first model by the manufacturer to have a pressure sensor albeit via an app. The Protectiveclean model that can meaningfully be compared Flexcare is the 6100 and a little bit with the 5100.
These two have quite some similarities: They all run on Sonicare’s patented sonic technology that makes 62000 movements per minute as you brush your teeth.
They both have a pressure sensor.
They both have a traveling case and dual voltage system. They can run on both 110v and 240v and therefore can be recharged anywhere in the world using the right socket plug.
Key differences between Sonicare ProtectiveClean 6100 vs. FlexCare
The Flexcare has a pressure that works via an app while the 6100 pressure sensor works through the BrushSync technology that is connected with the handle.
The Flexcare uses an app via Bluetooth while the 6100 has no Bluetooth connectivity.
Though they both have 3 cleaning modes they are a bit different. The FlexCare cleaning modes are (Deep clean, White and clean while the 6100 has gum care, clean and white cleaning modes).
The 6100 has the Brush Sync technology which automatically pairs the brush head to the appropriate cleaning mode. This feature is not available in the Flexcare.
The Flexcare has a UV sanitizer that keeps your brush head germ free through the use of ultraviolet rays. This feature is not available in the ProtectiveClean.
Sonicare Protectiveclean 5000 vs. Flexcare
They both have two buttons on the face of the handle. One button is the on/off button and the other is to toggle between the cleaning modes.
As with all Sonicare toothbrushes, they both make 32000 brush strokes that sweep fluids in between your teeth to form plaque fighting bubbles that are effective in removing plaque.
They both have pressure sensor although as already mentioned Flexcare’s pressure sensor uses the Sonicare app a feature that is not in the FlexCare.
Key Differences between ProtectiveClean 5100 vs Flexcare
The Flexcare has Bluetooth connectivity which is not in any of the protective clean modes.
The Flexcare platinum has Bluetooth connectivity that coaches you how to brush your teeth better.
The 5100 protective clean has three cleaning modes (clean, gum care and white) while the FlexCare plus and have five cleaning modes (clean, refresh, sensitive, massage and white). However, the FlexCare Platinum has three modes just like the 5100 (clean, white and gum care).
The Flexcare plus comes with two brush heads (pro-results for plaque control and gum Health for gum care). The Flexcare platinum comes with two Intercare brush head that improving your gum health.
The protective clean 5100 has BrushSync technology that tracks how long you have used the brush and reminds you to buy a new one. It also automatically pairs your brush head with the appropriate cleaning mode for optimum results.
On the balance of features and overall results, the Flexcare Platinum trounces the protective clean 5100 because it has more cleaning modes. It comes with two brush heads and more cleaning 4 cleaning modes compared to 3 in the 5100. The FlexCare has Bluetooth that will coach to brush your teeth better. The FlexCare Platinum has a UV sanitizer. However you are comparing the other Flexcare like the Flexcare Plus, then the 5100 offers better value for money because it has more or less the same feature as the Flexcare plus but it has a pressure sensor which will help you not to brush your teeth too hard. Brushing too hard can affect the health of your gums.
Sonicare healthy White vs Protectiveclean
- The Protectiveclean mode that fairly compares with Sonicare HealthyWhite is the 5100 and 6100.
- Of course, there are features that the HealthyWhite shares with the protective clean mode and these are:
- The 6100 and Sonicare HealthyWhite both have variable settings of low, medium and high that may be used to customize the brushing experience.
- Both the HealthyWhite and the protective clean 5100 and 6100 improves gum health in two weeks
- They both employ the sonic cleaning technology that is proven to remove more plaque than any manual toothbrush.
- They all have long-lasting batteries that are Lithium based that have two color (green and amber) battery indicators.
- They both come with a traveling case for convenient parking when traveling.
Key Differences between Sonicare HealthyWhite vs Protectiveclean 5100 and 6100
Perhaps the main difference is that the Protectiveclean 5100 and 6100 has a pressure sensor that helps to protect your gums from brushing too hard.
The HealthyWhite comes with hygienic caps and a traveler’s case while the Protectiveclean 5100 and 6100 only come with a standard traveling case.
HealthyWhite features only two cleaning modes (clean and white) while the 5100 and 6100 have three cleaning modes (gum case, clean and white).
The HealthyWhite comes with a DiamondClean brush head which is one of the best whitening brush head while the 5100 comes with the optimal gum care brush head and the 6100 comes with a white that is designed to whiten your teeth.
The Protectiveclean has the BrushSync feature that automatically pairs the brush head
Though the HealthyWhite has compelling features like more brushing settings (3 variable settings of low medium and high in addition to the two cleaning modes of white and clean) the protective clean has an edge over it because it has a pressure sensor and BrushSync that automatically syncs the brush head with the appropriate cleaning mode for effective cleaning. The BrushSync also intuitively tracks how long you have used your brush head to remind you to replace it. Given that the HealthyWhite is 20 dollars more expensive than the protectiveclean, then it follows that the ProtectiveClean provides more value for money.
Sonicare ProtectiveClean 4100 vs. 5100 vs. 6100 Comparison with Oral B
Well, the new improved mid-range Sonicare 4100, 5100 and 6100 seems to be an attempt by Sonicare to capture the mid-range electric toothbrush market. It could be argued that Sonicare probably has a greater market share of the high range market given how well its flagship premium toothbrush; DiamondClean is doing in the market.
Sonicare ProtectiveClean 4100 vs. 5100 vs 6100 Analysis
The new Sonicare 4100, 5100 and 6100 are improved versions of the current mid-range price models by Sonicare. For instance it the Sonicare Protective clean 4100 is an improved version of the Sonicare 2 series, the Protective clean 5100 is a revamped version of the Sonicare 3 Series gum control while the 6100 protective clean is a modified version of Sonicare HealthyWhite. The protective clean range has new features designed to match similar mid-range models by its main competitor Oral B.
Sonicare has not expressly called the protective clean models improved versions of current models in the market partly because some of their mid-range models like 2 Series and 3 Series are currently selling quite well and command a decent market share which Sonicare would not like to lose. However as an expert who has been reviewing Oral B and Sonicare models for ages. This is my hunch.
All mid-range Oral B models from the Oral B 1000, Oral B 3000, 4000 and Oral B 5000 have pressure sensors, LED light indicators, inbuilt timers, and quadpacer. They are also customized to cater for different conditions like the Oral B 3000 has gum care, sensitive teeth and daily clean. Some of these features like pressure sensor are not in Sonicare mid-price models. These new models are a direct response to these features that seemingly give Oral B an edge in the mid-priced electric toothbrush market.
Why should you choose the Protectiveclean 5100 over Oral B 3000
As always the battle between Oral B and Sonicare is never ending so its inevitable to consider how the protective performs in relation to comparatively similar toothbrushes from the Oral B range.
The Protectiveclean 5100 could be compared to Oral B 3000. These two have a pressure sensor.
Oral B has three cleaning modes (gum care, white and clean) just like the 5100. The thing that separates these two is the battery life and the Brush Sync feature present in the 5100 that automatically pairs a brush head to the right mode. Sonicare models have a longer battery life compared to Oral B. The manufacturer says the 5100 has a battery life of 14 days; however out testers got 28 days battery life on the 5100 (brushing for 2 minutes two times a day) after only one charge.
Our View and Verdict
Since these two have more or less the same features, the Sonicare 5100 has an edge over Oral B 3000 because in addition to all the features the Oral B 3000 has, the 5100 has a longer battery life of 14 days compared to the standard 7 days battery life in most Oral B toothbrushes. It also has Brush Sync feature that intuitively pairs any brush head to the appropriate cleaning mode for maximum cleaning efficiency and a travel case. The 5100 has LED light forThe Oral B has no travel case but offers Bluetooth connectivity. On the balance of all these features, the 5100 offers benefits like long battery life and traveling case that provide more value for money.