Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 4300 vs 5100 vs 6100 Review

Philips Sonicare Protectiveclean 4300, 5100 and 6100 models are the new mid-range electric toothbrushes models. They were commissioned in March 2018 to cater for the increased demand for gum care products hence the name ProtectiveClean.

Difference between Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 4300 , 5100 and 6100

  • Philips Sonicare Protectiveclean 4300 has one cleaning mode: daily clean, while, the 6100 and 5100 ProtectiveClean have three (clean, gum care and white).
  • Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 6100 and 5100 have an additional button on the handle to control the cleaning modes but, the 4300 ProtectiveClean however, does not have.
  • ProtectiveClean 4300 and 5100 have no cleaning intensity variations while, the  6100 Protectiveclean 6100  has 3 intensities (low, medium and high).
  • Varied intensities that are in the 6100 model give you more options to customize the brushing experience to suit your needs.
  • Philips Sonicare 4300 comes fitted with the plaque control brush head while, the 6100 features whitening brush head. And the Philips Sonicare 5100 has 2 brush head (the gum care, and optimal white).
  • You can buy any brush that will need your need at an extra cost and use it since the ProtectiveClean snap-on feature is compatible with most Sonicare brush heads.
  • Philips Sonicare Protectiveclean 5100 and 4300 have no brush sync pairing for cleaning modes, a feature that is available in the 6100 model.
  • The 6100 model comes in 5 colors (White silver, Black silver, deep purple, navy blue, and pink pastel ) the 5100 model comes in 4 colors (Turquoise, black grey, pastel pink and white). And the 4300 has (deep pink, navy blue, light blue, pink and black.
  • Philips Sonicare 6100 and 5100 come with a travelling case that is not available in the 4300 ProtectiveClean
  • Sonicare 4300 is cheaper than Protectiveclean 5100 and 6100. The 6100 costs more than the others.

Last update on 2023-06-02 at 18:55 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Philips Sonicare 4300 vs 5100 ProtectiveClean

  • Philips Sonicare Protectiveclean 4300 has one cleaning mode (the dailyclean) but 5100 has three (dailyClean, gum care and whitening)
  • Protectiveclean 4300 does not have cleaning mode buttons but the 5100 prominently features three cleaning modes on the brush handle.
  • There is LED illumination on the Protectiveclean 5100 buttons for cleaning mode while the 4300 does not have.
  • Philips Sonicare 5100 only has one standard intensity compared to 2 of the Protectiveclean 4300 (high and low)
  • Sonicare 5100 comes in four colours (Turquoise, Black Grey, Pastel Pink, White and Light Blue) while Protectiveclean 4300 comes in five colours (Pink, Black, Deep pink, Navy Blue and Light Blue).
  • Philips Sonicare 4300 though high spec  is considered a budget toothbrush while the Sonicare 5100 Protectiveclean is a mid-level budget electric toothbrush.
  • Protectiveclean 5100 is slightly more expensive than Protectiveclean 4300 .
  • So if you are looking for a toothbrush for basic teeth cleaning, the 4300 is what you want.
  • If you want more customization, the Protectiveclean 5100 is more suited for you because you get three cleaning modes that could help you achieve your desired results.
  • If is whitening your teeth, or managing the health of your gums and gum line then the Sonicare 5100 will do for you. It all boils down to your needs and the budget you set aside.
  • Our recommendation: the Sonicare 4300 has features like Brushsynch reminder to replace brush heads, quad pacers, two intensities and pressure sensor) are in high premium models.  It also has a standard cleaning that is sufficient for most teeth cleaning needs.

Philips Sonicare 4300 vs 6100 ProtectiveClean

Philips Sonicare 5100 vs 6100 ProtectiveClean

Both of these models are considered high-end products with the Philips Sonicare 6100 at the top. So what exactly differentiates them.

  • Philips Sonicare Protectiveclean 6100 has three intensities but 5100 ProtectiveClean does not have any.
  • The 6100 has low medium and high cleaning intensity variations.
  • Sonicare 6100 comes with two  white optimal brush heads while the 5100 electric toothbrush comes with two different brush heads: the optimal gum care and optimal white.
  • ProtectiveClean 6100 has brushsync cleaning mode pairing which is not available in the 5100 ProtectiveClean 5100
  • Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 5100 is in 4 colours  (black grey, turquoise (slightly greenish), white and pastel pink) while the 6100 comes in five different colours (light blue, navy blue, black, deep pink and pink)
  • Sonicare 5100 electric toothbrush is cheaper than the 6100 model

Sonicare 4300 Protectiveclean Review

Last update on 2023-06-02 at 22:23 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

The Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 4300 includes a handy case for travel. It comes with a pressure sensor, two-week battery life and also brush head replacement alerts thanks to the Sonicare Proprietary Brushnsync. Additionally, the 4300 Protectiveclean includes a two-minute timer, split into thirty-second intervals.


  • Smart brush head replacement alert
  • Pressure sensor and brushing timers
  • Handy travelling case for whenever you spend time from home


  • Expensive replacement toothbrush heads

The ProtectiveClean 4300 exists in 3 different colours. You are able to purchase it in white, light pink or even yellow. The brush is stylish and slim and surely looks the part. All 3 colours are going to look great on the bathroom shelf, although it’s worth noting that whichever colour you purchase the toothbrush heads which are provided are white.

The Philips electric-powered toothbrush comes with a pressure sensor. Your toothbrush stops automatically in case you are applying excessive pressure. 

A two-minute timer allows you to ensure that you clean as long as recommended by dentists. Split into thirty-second sections, additionally, it helps with brushing every quadrant of the mouth just for the correct amount of time.

The ProtectiveClean 4300 is unquestionably better than cleaning with a mechanical brush The integrated timer and pacer are extremely welcomed as would be the instant power off and EasyStart solutions.

Simplicity is available in the form of only one cleaning function, with the choice of switching the cleaning intensity between low and high.

The BrushSync replacement reminder is useful and clever and a remarkable illustration of just how technology may be utilized in very simple but powerful methods to enhance dental health.

Key Features of the Sonicare Protective Clean 4300:

Last update on 2023-06-02 at 22:23 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Comfortable and slim brush handle; Different colour options; Sonic cleansing activity with up to 62,000 motions per minute; One cleaning mode; Two brushing intensities (low and high); One brush head included; Different designs of brush head offered separately; Brush head ; replacement reminder; EasyStart programme; Built-in timer along with thirty-second pacer; A pressure sensor to prevent you from brushing too hard; Travel case included; 2+ week battery life; Water-resistant handle; Warranty of two years.

Sonicare 5100 Review

Last update on 2023-06-02 at 18:31 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 5100

The ProtectiveClean 5100 features of BrushSync technology which reminds you to get a new brush head as soon as your brush-head needs changing. So you are assured of optimal results every single time you brush.

It has a pressure sensor that alerts you whenever you apply excessive force while brushing. The pressure sensor prevents damage to your gums.

Colour variations:

  1. The White and Light Blue colored brush which is the only version that comes with a single brush head for optimum gum care.
  2. The Pastel Pink, (comes with two brush heads)
  3. Turquoise (has two brush heads)
  4. There are three versions of the Black Grey: the HX6850/10 which comes with two brush heads (optimal gum care and optimal white ),the HX6850/39 that comes with two optimal white brush heads and a travel case and the HX6850/57 that has only one optimal white brush head and a UV sanitizer.


  • Like most Sonicare toothbrushes, the 5100 employs the sonic technology that makes up to 31,000 bristle motions per second.
  • It has three modes for cleaning: Whitening, thoroughly clean and gum care.
  • A Timer and a pacer (alerts you to move sections after every 30 seconds)
  • Auto Power Off
  • Replace Brush Head Reminder (BrushSync)
  • Exceptionally long battery life.
  • A protective traveling case (HX6850/39) helps defend the brush head and also keeps your brush handle secure when travelling.


  • It;s a bit pricey.

Review of design

The Sonicare ProtectiveClean 5100 is quite ergonomic with rounded and smooth edges which makes holding and operating it effortless. It has a sleek matte finish and a good range of colours to suit different tastes.

You can pick from white, light blue, black grey, turquoise as well as pastel pink.

It has three cleaning modes: Clean, White and Gum Care is printed underneath. The cleaning modes are highlighted by LED light when active. In case you a wish to pick a certain method, simply keep on pressing the performance button until the corresponding LED lighting comes on.

The ProtectiveClean 5100 brush handle intuitively recalls the last cleaning mode used whenever you turn it on. In case you desire another mode, only cycle through options by pressing the button in, the LED corresponding to the preferred mode glows..

Cleaning modes:

The regular mode is Clean that runs for two minutes, giving the teeth a thorough and complete cleanse. Every thirty seconds the brush stops briefly which means you are able to shift to another quadrant in the mouth.

In the event that you would like to shift to among another 2 modes, simply press the button until the mode you are looking for is highlighted by the LED light.

The White mode, lasts two minutes thirty seconds. After the 1st two minutes, the brush runs for an additional thirty seconds during which you make use of the brush to whiten the front teeth.

In Gum Care function, the electrical toothbrush lasts for three minutes. The first two minutes are for cleaning. The extra one minute is for massaging, cleaning and stimulating blood flow in the gums for healthy gums.

Travel case

At the time of writing only the ProtectiveClean 5100 HX6850/39 had a travelling case included. A travel case is able to store the toothbrush handle as well as up to two additional brush heads


The 5100 has many excellent features which validate the additional price

The various cleaning modes and speeds, make it ideal for people with a variety of oral health needs

Sonicare 6100 Review

Last update on 2023-06-02 at 22:23 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

The ProtectiveClean 6100 feels akin to Sonicares most premium version in the market at the time of writing, the DiamondClean Smart. It boasts, some of the functions of the Smart, but is actually a more affordable alternative. it’s gentler on gums and teeth.

Main Features

  • Three different modes of cleaning (Gum Care ,White and Clean)
  • Three brushing intensities
  • Built-in pressure sensor
  • Two minute timer as well as thirty second pacer
  • Automatic energy off
  • Brush head reminder system
  • Automatic cleaning mode selection
  • Traveling case

Pro & Cons

The Positives

  • Design – Comfortable to hold, the brush is packaged in many color choices to suit your style.
  • Three cleaning modes – This gives you options of cleaning modes to get the cleaning results you would like complete.
  • Brushing intensity – This gives you the flexibility to vary the intensity at which the bristles oscillate. For whitening and plaque removing you might want to choose low intensity while for gum care and sensitivity the low intensity will give you better results and experience.
  • Built-in timer and pacer – Get warnings of when it’s some time to change quadrant, which means you are able to clean your teeth evenly.
  • BrushSync – A method which alerts you when it’s some time to change the brush head, but likewise auto-selects the best cleaning mode for the brush head installed to the handle.
  • Pressure sensor – you get vibration in the brush handle alerts you if you are brushing way too hard.
  • Automatic energy off – Such an easy but powerful option which saves battery power and lets you know when you are done cleaning.
  • Battery life – you get at-leat 10-14 solid days after just one full charge.
  • Travel case – the 6100 comes with a protective plastic case to keep the brush head which is especially handy when traveling.

The Negatives

  • Pressure sensor – Would be much better in case it was a noticeable pressure sensor, flipping on a light to alert you or better still a combination of vibration and flashing light…
  • BrushSync – In order to take full advantage of the BrushSync characteristic you have to purchase extra brush heads. Not all Sonicare brush heads are compatible with the BrushSync.
  • Brush head cost – New’ BrushSync’ suitable heads are usually a lot more costly.

Different Versions of the Philips ProtectiveClean 6100

In order to make things a bit confusing, the ProtectiveClean 6100 comes in different variants. Technically the toothbrush handle is precisely the same with all variants, but what changes is actually the color of the brush handle.

The ProtectiveClean 6100 will come with a range of style choices which makes it attractive to users. Rather than being stuck with a clinical White, you get five distinct colors –

  • Pastel Pink
  • White-colored Silver
  • Navy Blue
  • Black
  • Deep Purple

Several of these designs are available with colored brush heads, charging stands or maybe travel cases to fit. Technical capabilities and the layout is usually identical.

Brushing Modes and Cleaning Intensity

The brush head has an on and off button. An additional button adjusts the brushing intensity. Pressing it repeatedly cycles through various intensity settings.

3 LEDs arranged horizontally indicate the intensity. Another sequence of vertically aligned LEDs lets you know what cleaning modes are actually out there – Clean, White and Gum Care.

There is an indicator at the base of the brush head to show battery charge levels to indicate when it’s time to recharge your toothbrush.

The Sonicare ProtectiveClean 6100 offers three different cleaning modes. You are also able to modify brushing intensity between 3 settings – low, moderate and high.

Cleaning Modes Explained

Clean mode: takes a two minute cycle for complete cleaning

White mode is actually a two minutes and thirty seconds cycle that is mainly used to polish front side teeth

Gum Care mode is a three minute session, including one minute for rubbing gums

Other Features Explained

  • An inbuilt two minute timer ensures you comply with the dentist recommended length for cleaning teeth.
  • Automatic cut-off functionality limits battery life by shutting down the brush after a washing session ends.
  • A quad pacer included in the 6100 indicates when it’s some time to move to an additional quadrant.
  • A pressure sensor limits the pressure you are use while brushing. When you press down way too tough, the sensor detects the issue and turns off power to the motor.
  • BrushSync is actually a technology that is made to allow you to recognize if the brush heads are actually frayed and require replacement. Another benefit is mode pairing’, the 6100 brush instantly senses the sort of brush head you’re using, as well as changes the cleaning mode to complement it. It will help you attain the most effective cleaning results.

For this to happen, the brush heads also ought to be BrushSync compatible.

Brush Head Compatible with BrushSync

  • W2 Optimal White
  • Optimal Gum Care
  • Optimal Plaque Defence
  • Premium White
  • Gum Care Premium
  • Premium Plaque Defence

In case you are searching for a good power toothbrush that’s useful at achieving good dental hygiene, has a range of valuable characteristics, and is actually valued at a reasonable price-range, then the ProtectiveClean 6100 might be your ideal electric toothbrush for you.

Which is Better, Philips Sonicare 4300 , 5100 or 6100 ?

The new Philips Sonicare Protectiveclean are improved versions of the current mid-range price models by Sonicare. For instance the 4300 is an improved version of the Sonicare 2 series, the Protectiveclean 5100 is a revamped version of the Sonicare 3 Series gum control while the ProtectiveClean 6100 is a modified version of Sonicare HealthyWhite. The protective clean range has new features designed to match similar mid-range models by its main competitor Oral B.

Sonicare has not expressly called the protectiveclean models improved versions of current models in the market partly because some of their mid-range models like 2 Series and 3 Series are currently selling quite well and command a decent market share which Sonicare would not like to lose. However, as an expert who has been reviewing Oral B and Sonicare models for ages. This is my hunch.

All mid-range Oral B models from Oral B 1000, Oral B 3000, 4000 and Oral B Pro 5000 have pressure sensors, LED light indicators, inbuilt timers, and quad pacer. They are also customized to cater for different conditions like Oral B 3000 has gum care, sensitive teeth and daily clean. Some of these features like pressure sensor are not in Sonicare mid-price models. These new models are a direct response to these features that seemingly give Oral B an edge in the mid-priced electric toothbrush market.

For USA, check Philips Sonicare 4100 vs 5100 vs 6100 ProtectiveClean.

As you will notice, there is a common thread running through all these protective clean models. However, a few differences exist as pointed out. The ProtectiveClean 6100 is the one with most features followed by 5100 and then the 4300. The thing that separates the 5100 and 6100 from 4300 appears to be on the cleaning modes.  The 4300 has only one mode: Clean. The clean mode runs for two minutes as recommended by dentists and has a quad pacer that reminds you when you need to move from one quadrant of the mouth to the next when brushing your teeth.

The White cleaning mode runs for two and a half minutes. The extra half-minute is used to whiten your front teeth. The white mode is generally on the high intensity that polishes your front teeth to reduce any colouration as it whitens the teeth.

The gum care runs for three minutes, two minutes for cleaning your teeth as recommended by dentists and the added minute for cleaning under the gum line to stimulate your gums. Gum care is generally gentle and low intensity so as not to damage your gums.

The other noticeable difference is the number of buttons on the handles. The 4300 has no other button apart from the power button while the 5100 and 6100 have additional buttons below the power button and LED illuminated display under the cleaning modes inscribed on the handle. The LED is activated when a cleaning mode is activated

The rotectiveclean 4300 has two intensities (high and low), this means that in spite of having different cleaning modes, you can use the intensity levels to vary the way you clean your teeth and to suit your needs.

The 5100 has no intensity setting and therefore the different cleaning modes run on factory default setting to give the best results.

The Sonicare 6100 has three intensities (low, medium and high) which are controlled by a button under the power button. The different intensities give you control on the sensation and intensity of the brushing. The low setting can be quite gentle and soothing especially on sensitive teeth.

The brush heads also differ. The C2 Optimal plaque defence which works well with the clean mode. The C2 plaque defence removes seven times more plaque than a normal manual toothbrush.

G2 Optimal gums is quite compatible with the gum care mode and improves the health of your gums,

The W2 Optimal White pairs well with the White cleaning mode and it reduces stains on your teeth in less than a week.

Last update on 2023-06-02 at 18:55 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Philips Sonicare 4300 vs 5100 vs 6100, which one is better?

Similar Posts:

Scroll to Top