Compare Philips Sonicare 4300 vs 5100 vs 6100 ProtectiveClean : These new electric toothbrushes models were launched in the summer of 2018. They have two core functionality that cuts through them: pressure sensor and synch which automatically detects when the brush head is due for a change and alerts you about it.
Of the three models, the Sonicare 4300 is the the budget option of the protective range, the 5100 is the md-range option while the 6100 is the high end option. So what exactly separates these models?
Philips Sonicare 4300 VS 5100
- The ProtectiveClean 4300 has two cleaning intensities (high and low) while the Philips Sonicare 5100 only has one standard intensity.
- The Sonicare 4300 operates on one standard cleaning mode: clean while the 5100 features 3 cleaning modes Clean, sensitive/gum care and white
- Since the 4300 has only one cleaning mode, it does not have cleaning mode buttons. The 5100 prominently features three cleaning modes on the brush handle.
- The 4300 designed to compact plaque and comes with one C2 brush that is optimised for plaque removal while the 5100 comes with a brush head designed for gum care.
- The 5100 comes in four colours (Turquoise, Black Grey, Pastel Pink, White and Light Blue) while the 4300 comes in five colours (Pink, Black, Deep pink, Navy Blue and Light Blue).
- The 4300 though high spec is considered a budget toothbrush while the 5100 is a mid-level budget electric toothbrush.
- There is LED illumination on the Philips Sonicare 5100 buttons for cleaning mode while the 4300 does not have.
- The 4300 has no cleaning modes because it only has one standard mode while the 5100 has cleaning modes emblazoned on the brush head.
Our recommendation: the Sonicare 4300 has features like Brushsynch reminder to replace brush heads, quad pacers, two intensities and pressure sensor) are in high premium models. It also has a standard cleaning that is sufficient for most teeth cleaning needs. The key difference the 5100 has over 4300 is that it has 3 cleaning modes (Gum care, Clean and White) and comes with 2 brush heads as opposed to the 4300 that only has one standard clean . The 4300 is more suited for plaque removal and control while 5100 is all about gum care. The 5100 is slightly more expensive than the 4300 so if you are looking for a toothbrush for basic teeth cleaning, the 4300 is what you want. However if you want more customization, the Philips Sonicare 5100 is more suited for you because you get three cleaning modes that could help you achieve your desired results. If is whitening your teeth, or managing the health of your gums and gum line then the Sonicare ProtectiveClean 5100 will do for you. It all boils down to your needs and the budget you set aside.
Philips Sonicare 6100 vs 4300
The Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 6100 is the most premium of the protectiveclean range. So what exactly sets it apart from the 4300 which is at the bottom of the protectiveclean range?
Cleaning models: The 6100 has three cleaning models (Daily clean, white and sensitive/gum care) compared to the 4300 that only comes with one cleaning mode (Clean).
Cleaning mode intensities: The 6100 comes fitted with three cleaning mode intensities (high, medium and low) while the 4300 has only two intensities (high and low).
Icons on the handle: the 6100 has LED buttons for cleaning mode icons and intensity on the handle unlike the 4300.
Brush heads: The 6100 comes with two White optimal brush heads (2 X W2) while the 4300 only has one brush head (C2) that is optimised for plaque removal.
BrushSync pairing: The 6100 has brushsync pairing for cleaning modes and one for reminder to replace brush heads. On the other hand the 4300 only has brushsync pairing for brush head replacement reminder.
Colour range option: The 6100 comes in five different colours (Silver, white, deep purple, black silver and navy ). Meanwhile the 4300 has different colours to those of 6100, here they are (light blue,navy blue, black, deep pink and pink).
Check the Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 6100.
Philips Sonicare 6100 vs 5100
Both of these models are considered high end products with the 6100 at the top. So what exactly differentiates them.
The Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 6100 features 3 cleaning mode intensity settings (low, medium and high) while the 5100 does not feature and cleaning mode intensity, it only has cleaning modes that are designed to achieve a desired result e.g gum case, whitening or daily clean.
The 6100 comes with two White optimal brush heads while the 5100 comes with two different brush heads: the optimal gum care and optimal white.
The 6100 has brushsync cleaning mode pairing which is not available in the 5100
The 6100 ProtectiveClean comes in five different colours (light blue,navy blue, black, deep pink and pink) while the 5100 is in 4 colours (black grey, turquoise (slightly greenish), white and pastel pink)
Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean Reviews in Summary:
As you will notice, there is a common thread running through all these protective clean models. However a few differences exist as pointed out. The 6100 is the one with most features followed by 5100 and then the 4300. The thing that separates the 5100 and 6100 from the 4300 appears to be on the cleaning modes. The 4300 has only one mode: Clean. The clean mode runs for two minutes as recommended by dentists and has a quad pacer that reminds you when you need to move from one quadrant of the mouth to the next when brushing your teeth.
The White cleaning mode runs for two and a half minutes. The extra half minute is used to whiten your front teeth. The white mode is generally on high intensity that polishes your front teeth to reduce any colouration as it whitens the teeth.
The gum care runs for three minutes, two minutes for cleaning your teeth as recommended by dentists and the added minute for cleaning under the gum line to stimulate your gums. Gum care is generally gentle and low intensity so as not to damage your gums.
The other noticeable difference is the number of buttons on the handles. The 4300 has no other button apart from the power button while the 5100 and 6100 has additional buttons below the power button and LED illuminated display under the cleaning modes inscribed on the handle. The LED is activated when a cleaning mode is activated
The 4300 has two intensities (high and low), this means that in spite of having different cleaning modes, you can use the intensity levels to vary the way you clean your teeth and to suite your needs.
The 5100 has no intensity setting and therefore the different cleaning modes run on factory default setting to give the best results.
The Philips Sonicare ProtectiveClean 6100 has three intensities (low, medium and high) which are controlled by a button under the power button. The different intensities give you control on the sensation and intensity of the brushing. The low setting can be quite gentle and soothing especially on sensitive teeth.
The brush heads also differ. The C2 Optimal plaque defence which works well with the clean mode. The C2 plaque defence removes seven times more plaque than a normal manual toothbrush.
G2 Optimal gums is quite compatible with the gum care mode and improves the health of your gums,
The W2 Optimal White pairs well with the White cleaning mode and it reduces stains on your teeth in less than a week.