Quick Answer
Both Colgate Total and Crest Pro-Health are excellent ADA-approved toothpastes that effectively fight cavities, gingivitis, and plaque. Colgate Total uses triclosan for 12-hour antibacterial protection, while Crest Pro-Health relies on stannous fluoride for comprehensive oral health benefits.
Key Points:
- Both have ADA Seal of Acceptance and proven clinical effectiveness
- Colgate Total offers 12-hour antibacterial protection with triclosan
- Crest Pro-Health uses stannous fluoride for cavity and gum disease prevention
Colgate Totaland Crest Pro-Healthare two of the most popular and clinically-supported toothpaste brands on the market. Both have the American Dental Association (ADA) Seal of Acceptance and are designed to provide comprehensive protection against cavities, gingivitis, and plaque. However, they achieve these benefits through different primary active ingredients and have some distinct differences.
.
.
Key Active Ingredients:
- Colgate Total traditionally used an antibacterial agent called triclosan along with fluoride to provide its benefits. However, with concerns about triclosan, many of its newer formulations have switched to using stannous fluoride (like Crest) along with other ingredients like zinc to fight bacteria. This provides 12-hour protection against plaque and gingivitis.
- Crest Pro-Health has long relied on stannous fluoride as its key active ingredient. Stannous fluoride is a highly effective antimicrobial agent that not only helps prevent cavities but also fights plaque and gingivitis. Crest Pro-Healthalso often includes ingredients like zinc lactate and sodium hexametaphosphate, which helps control tartar and prevent stains.
Performance and Benefits:
- Plaque and Gingivitis: Both toothpastes are highly effective in fighting plaque and gingivitis. Some clinical studies have shown that Colgate Totalcan be more effective at inhibiting plaque formation over a 24-hour period.
- Tooth Sensitivity: Crest Pro-Health, due to its stannous fluoride formulation, has a strong reputation and more clinical evidence for its effectiveness in reducing tooth sensitivity.
- Staining: Both toothpastes help prevent and remove surface stains. Some users of Crest Pro-Health have reported a slight increase in staining, but the company often addresses this with specific formulas that include ingredients to counteract this effect.
- User Experience: Preferences often come down to taste and texture. Colgate Totalis sometimes described as having a stronger, more intense flavor, while Crest Pro-Health is known for a milder taste and smoother texture, which some users with sensitive gums prefer.
Conclusion:
Both Colgate Total and Crest Pro-Health are excellent choices that provide multi-benefit protection for your oral health.
- Choose Colgate Totalif you are looking for comprehensive, long-lasting protection against plaque and gingivitis.
-
- Choose Crest Pro-Healthif you have sensitive teeth, or you are looking for a toothpaste with more evidence for reducing sensitivity, in addition to fighting cavities and plaque.
Ultimately, the best choice is often a matter of personal preference and which formula best addresses your specific oral health needs.
Best selling toothpastes:
.
.
